Preparing for a "dirty bomb" attack: The optimum mix of medical countermeasure resources

Alexis Rump; Patrick Ostheim; Stefan Eder; Cornelius Hermann; Michael Abend; Matthias Port

doi:10.1186/s40779-020-00291-3

Your Location：

Home >

Browse articles >

Preparing for a "dirty bomb" attack: The optimum mix of medical countermeasure resources

RESEARCH | Updated：2023-02-28

- Preparing for a "dirty bomb" attack: The optimum mix of medical countermeasure resources
- Military Medical Research Vol. 8, Issue 3, Pages: 336-351(2021)
- Affiliations：
  
  Bundeswehr Institute of Radiobiology, Neuherberg Str. 11, 80937 Munich, Germany
- Author bio：
  
  * AlexisRump@bundeswehr.org
- Funds：
- DOI：10.1186/s40779-020-00291-3
  CLC：
- Published：2021-09
- Accepted：
Scan QR Code
Rump et al.: Preparing for a "dirty bomb" attack: The optimum mix of medical countermeasure resources. Mil Med Res, 2021, 8: 3.
DOI：

Rump et al.: Preparing for a "dirty bomb" attack: The optimum mix of medical countermeasure resources. Mil Med Res, 2021, 8: 3. DOI： 10.1186/s40779-020-00291-3.

摘要

Abstract

Background:

In radiological emergencies with radionuclide incorporation

decorporation treatment is particularly effective if started early. Treating all people potentially contaminated ( "urgent treatment" ) may require large antidote stockpiles. An efficacious way to reduce antidote requirements is by using radioactivity screening equipment. We analyzed the suitability of such equipment for triage purposes and determined the most efficient mix of screening units and antidote daily doses.

Methods:

The committed effective doses corresponding to activities within the detection limits of monitoring portals and mobile whole-body counters were used to assess their usefulness as triage tools. To determine the optimal resource mix

we departed from a large-scale scenario (60

000 victims) and based on purchase prices of antidotes and screening equipment in Germany

we calculated efficiencies of different combinations of medical countermeasure resources by data envelopment analysis. Cost-effectiveness was expressed as the costs per life year saved and compared to risk reduction opportunities in other sectors of society as well as the values of a statistical life.

Results:

Monitoring portals are adequate instruments for a sensitive triage after cesium-137 exposure with a high screening throughput. For the detection of americium-241 whole-body counters with a lower daily screening capacity per unit are needed. Assuming that 1% of the potentially contaminated patients actually need decorporation treatment

an efficient resource mix includes 6 monitoring portals and 25 mobile whole-body counters. The optimum mix depends on price discounts and in particular the fraction of victims actually needing treatment. The cost-effectiveness of preparedness for a "dirty bomb" attack is less than for common health care

but costs for a life year saved are less than for many risk-reduction interventions in the environmental sector.

Conclusion:

To achieve economic efficiency a high daily screening capacity is of major importance to substantially decrease the required amount of antidote doses. Among the determinants of the number of equipment units needed

the fraction of the potentially contaminated victims that actually needs treatment is the most difficult to assess. Judging cost-effectiveness of the preparedness for "dirty bomb" attacks is an issue of principle that must be dealt with by political leaders.

关键词

Keywords

references

Edsall K . Radiological and nuclear incidents and terrorism . In: Walter FG , editor . Advanced hazmat life support (AHLS) provider manual . Tucson : University of Arizona Emergency Medicine Research Center & American Academy of Clinical Toxicology ; 2003 .

NCRP . Population monitoring and radionuclide decorporation following a radiological or nuclear accident . National Council on Radiation Protection and Measurements : Bethesda ; 2010 .

Stricklin D , Millage K , Rodriguez J , McClellan G . Americium-241 decorporation model. Technical report DTRA-TR-15-02 . Fort Belvoir : Defense Threat Reduction Agency ; 2014 .

International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) . The radiological accident in Goiânia . Vienna : International Atomic Energy Agency ; 1988 .

Krock L , Deusser R . Dirty bomb homepage. Chronology of events . Nova Science Programming on Air and Online ; 2003 . https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/dirtybomb/chrono.html https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/dirtybomb/chrono.html . Accessed 20 Nov 2019 .

Hall EJ , Giaccia AJ . Radiobiology for the radiologist . Philadelphia : Lippincott Williams & Wilkins ; 2006 .

Radiology Key . Radiologic terrorism . https://radiologykey.com/radiologicterrorism/ https://radiologykey.com/radiologicterrorism/ . Accessed 10 Jan 2020 .

Von Winterfeldt D , Rosoff H . A risk and economic analysis of dirty bomb attacks on the ports of Los Angeles and Long Beach . Risk Anal . 2007 ; 27 ( 3 ): 533 - 46 .

Haines JR . “Dirty bomb”: Reason to worry? Explosive radiological dispersal devices and the distribution of dangerous radiological material worldwide . Philadelphia : Foreign Policy Research Institute (FPRI) E-notes ; 2014 . https://www.fpri.org/article/2014/07/dirty-bombs-reason-to-worry/ https://www.fpri.org/article/2014/07/dirty-bombs-reason-to-worry/ . Accessed 10 Jan 2020 .

Connell LW . Dirty bomb risk and impact. A systems analysis overview. Contract DENA0003525 for the US Department of Energy: Sandia National Laboratories ; 2017 . https://prod-ng.sandia.gov/techlib-noauth/access-control.cgi/2017/179121r.pdf https://prod-ng.sandia.gov/techlib-noauth/access-control.cgi/2017/179121r.pdf . Accessed 15 Jan 2020 .

Harper FT , Musolino SV , Wente WB . Realistic radiological dispersal device hazard boundaries and ramifications for early consequence management decisions . Health Phys . 2007 ; 93 ( 1 ): 1 - 16 .

Andersson KG , Mikkelsen T , Astrup P , Thykier-Nielsen S , Jacobsen LH , Schou-Jensen L , et al . Estimation of health hazards resulting from a radiological terrorist attack in a city . Radiat Prot Dosim . 2008 ; 131 ( 3 ): 297 - 307 . https://doi.org/10.1093/rpd/ncn173 https://doi.org/10.1093/rpd/ncn173 .

Rump A , Becker B , Eder S , Lamkowski A , Abend M , Port M . Medical management of victims contaminated with radionuclides after a “dirty bomb” attack . Mil Med Res . 2018 ; 5 ( 1 ): 27 .

Yan T , Lin G , Wang M , Lamkowski A , Port M , Rump A . Pharmacological treatment of inhalation injury after nuclear or radiological incidents: the German and Chinese approach . Mil Med Res . 2019 ; 6 ( 1 ): 10 .

Weickhardt U . Der Strahlenunfall. Informationsschrift zur Behandlung von Strahlenverletzten . Luzern : Schweizerische Unfallversicherungsanstalt Arbeitsmedizin ; 2001 .

Roessler G . Why Po-210? Health Phys News . 2007 ; 35 ( 2 ): 1 - 9 https://hps.org/documents/polonium_210_story.pdf https://hps.org/documents/polonium_210_story.pdf . Accessed 15 June 2020 .

Altagracia-Martinez M , Kravzov-Jinich J , Martínez-Núnez JM , Ríos-Castaneda C , López-Naranjo F . Prussian blue as an antidote for radioactive thallium and cesium poisoning . Orphan Drugs: ResRev . 2012 ; 2 : 13 - 21 .

Melo DR , Lipsztein JL , Leggett R , Bertelli L , Guilmette R . Efficacy of Prussian blue on 137 Cs decorporation therapy . Health Phys . 2014 ; 106 ( 5 ): 592 - 7 .

Rump A , Stricklin D , Lamkowski A , Eder S , Abend M , Port M . Reconsidering current decorporation strategies after incorporation of radionuclides . Health Phys . 2016 ; 111 ( 2 ): 201 - 8 .

Rump A , Stricklin D , Lamkowski A , Eder S , Abend M , Port M . The impact of time on decorporation efficacy after a “dirty bomb” attack studied by simulation . Drug Res . 2016 ; 66 ( 11 ): 607 - 13 .

Rump A , Stricklin D , Lamkowski A , Eder S , Abend M , Port M . The incorporation of radionuclides after wounding by a “dirty bomb”: the impact of time for decorporation efficacy and a model for cases of disseminated fragmentation wounds . Adv Wound Care . 2017 ; 6 ( 1 ): 1 - 9 .

Grappin L , Berard P , Beau P , Carbone L , Castagnet X , Courtay C , et al . Exposition aux actinides. Bilan injection de Ca-DTPA dans les centres CEACogema. Rapport CEA-R-6097 . Gif-sur-Yvette : Commissariat à l’Energie Atomique ; 2006 .

Rump A , Stricklin D , Lamkowski A , Eder S , Abend M , Port M . Analysis of the antidote requirements and outcomes of different radionuclide decorporation strategies for a scenario of a “dirty bomb” attack . Am J Disaster Med . 2017 ; 12 ( 4 ): 227 - 41 .

Perez M , Carr Z . Development of stockpiles for radiation emergencies. Report of the radio-nuclear working group. WHO consultation meeting on development of stockpiles for radiation and chemical emergencies . Geneva : World Health Organization ; 2007 .

Liste G . Fachinformation Radiogardase ® -Cs Kaps . Gelbe Liste : Pharmindex ; 2015 . https://www.gelbe-liste.de/produkte/radiogardase-cs-kaps_253011/fachinformation https://www.gelbe-liste.de/produkte/radiogardase-cs-kaps_253011/fachinformation . Accessed 10 Nov 2019 .

Liste G . Fachinformation Ditripentat-Heyl ® (DTPA) . Gelbe Liste : Pharmindex ; 2015 . https://www.gelbe-liste.de/medikamente/ditripentat-heyl-dtpa_254276/fachinformation https://www.gelbe-liste.de/medikamente/ditripentat-heyl-dtpa_254276/fachinformation . Accessed 10 Nov 2019 .

Homeland Security Council (HSC) . Radiological attack – Radiological dispersal devices, Scenario 11 . In: HSC . Planning scenarios. Executive summaries. Version 2.0 ; 2004 . http://www.globalsecurity.org/security/library/report/2004/hscplanning-scenarios-jul04_execsum.pdf http://www.globalsecurity.org/security/library/report/2004/hscplanning-scenarios-jul04_execsum.pdf . Accessed 8 Oct 2019 .

Youngman MJ . Review of methods to measure internal contamination in an emergency . J Radiol Prot . 2015 ; 35 ( 2 ): R1 - R15 .

Wood R , Sharp C , Gourmelon P , Le Guen B , Stradling GN , Taylor DM , et al . Decorporation treatment – medical overview . Radiat Protect Dosim . 2000 ; 87 ( 1 ): 51 - 7 .

Ménétrier F , Grappin L , Raynaud P , Courtay C , Wood R , Joussineau S , et al . Treatment of accidental intakes of plutonium and americium: guidance notes . Appl Radiat Isot . 2005 ; 62 ( 6 ): 829 - 46 .

Rojas-Palma C , Liland A , Jerstad AN , Etherington G , del Rosario PM , Rahola T , et al . TMT Handbook. Triage, monitoring and treatment of people exposed to ionizing radiation following a malevolent act . Osteras : Norwegian Radiation Protection Authority (NRPA) ; 2009 .

Mirion Technologies (RADOS) GmbH . CheckPoint: Gate TM FastTrack-Fibre TM Mobile . Technisches Handbuch ; 2017 .

Birchall A , Puncher M , Marsh JW , Davis K , Bailey MR , Jarvis NS , et al . IMBA professional plus: a flexible approach to internal dosimetry . Radiat Prot Dosim . 2007 ; 125 : 194 - 7 .

Autorité de Sureté Nucléaire (ASN) . Guide national. Intervention médicale en cas d’évènement nucléaire ou radiologique. Version V 3.6 ; 2008 . https://professionnels.asn.fr/Installations-nucleaires/Guides-de-l-ASN-domaine-des-dechets-radioactifs-et-dudemantelement/Guide-national-d-intervention-medicale-en-cas-d-evenementnucleaire-ou-radiologique https://professionnels.asn.fr/Installations-nucleaires/Guides-de-l-ASN-domaine-des-dechets-radioactifs-et-dudemantelement/Guide-national-d-intervention-medicale-en-cas-d-evenementnucleaire-ou-radiologique . Accessed 15 Nov 2019 .

Premier Ministre . Secrétariat général de la défense et de la sécurité nationale. Circulaire relative à doctrine nationale d'emploi des moyens de secours et de soins face à une action terroriste mettant en oeuvre des matières radioactives . http://circulaire.legifrance.gouv.fr/pdf/2011/03/cir_32735.pdf http://circulaire.legifrance.gouv.fr/pdf/2011/03/cir_32735.pdf . Accessed 15 Nov 2019 .

Oka T . Application of cost-benefit analysis to the regulation of foodstuffs contaminated with radioactive substances . Jpn J Health Phys . 2012 ; 47 ( 3 ): 181 - 8 .

U.S. Department of Health and Human Services . Public health emergency. national planning scenario # 11 . Washington DC ; 2015 . https://www.phe.gov/Preparedness/planning/playbooks/rdd/Pages/scenario.aspx https://www.phe.gov/Preparedness/planning/playbooks/rdd/Pages/scenario.aspx . Accessed 10 Jan 2020 .

Coelli TJ , Prasada Rao DS , O'Donnel CJ , Battese GE . An introduction to efficiency and productivity analysis. 2nd . Berlin : Springer Science and Business Media ; 2005 . http://facweb.knowlton.ohio-state.edu/pviton/courses/crp394/coelli_Intro_effic.pdf http://facweb.knowlton.ohio-state.edu/pviton/courses/crp394/coelli_Intro_effic.pdf . Accessed 15 Nov 2019 .

Besstremyannaya G . The impact of Japanese hospital financing reform on hospital efficiency: a difference-indifference approach . Jpn Econ Rev . 2013 ; 64 ( 3 ): 337 - 62 .

Asandului L , Roman M , Fatulescu P . The efficiency of healthcare systems in Europe: a data envelopment analysis approach . Procedia Econ Financ . 2014 ; 10 : 261 - 8 .

Rump A , Schöffski O . Pregnancy care in Germany, France and Japan: an international comparison of quality and efficiency using structural equation modelling and data envelopment analysis . Public Health . 2018 ; 160 : 129 - 42 .

Stepan A , Fischer E . Betriebswirtschaftliche Optimierung . München : Oldenbourg Wissenschaftsverlag ; 2009 .

Rääf CL , Falk R , Lauridsen B , Rahola T , Skuterud L , Soogard-Hansen S . Human metabolism of caesium . Roskilde : Department of Radiation physics in Malmö, Lund University (SE), Swedish Radiation Protection Authority (SE), Risø National Laboratory (DK), STUK- Radiation and Nuclear Safety Authority (FI), NRPA-Norwegian Radiation Protection Authority (NO) ; 2006 .

Youngman MJ . Transportable system for monitoring internal radioactive contamination in people . Public Health England . London : PHE Publications ; 2017 .

Rump A , Eder S , Lamkowski A , Hermann C , Abend M , Port M . A quantitative comparison of the chemo- and radiotoxicity of uranium at different enrichment grades . Toxicology Lett . 2019 ; 313 : 159 - 68 .

Bundesamt für Justiz . Verordnung zum Schutz vor der schädlichen Wirkung ionisierender Strahlung . 2018 . https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/strlschv_2018/ https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/strlschv_2018/ . Accessed 10 Jan 2020 .

Rodrigues M , Chaput J , Bellman C , Cousins T . Children as vulnerable populations in radiological/nuclear events: discussion scenarios . Radiat Prot Dosim . 2010 ; 142 ( 1 ): 77 - 82 .

Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) . Pharmaceutical pricing policies in a global market . Paris : OECD Publishing ; 2008 .

Haupt J , Kaatsch HL , Eder SF , Port M , Rump A . Medizinische Strahlenschutzaktivitäten des Instituts für Radiobiologie der Bundeswehr . Strahlenschutz Praxis . 2019 ; 25 ( 3 ): 20 - 5 .

Da Silva CJ , Delgado JU , Luiz MTB , Cunha PG , De Barros PD . Considerations related to the decontamination of houses in Goiânia: limitations and implications . Health Phys . 1991 ; 60 ( 1 ): 87 - 90 .

Andersson KG , Mikkelsen T , Astrup P , Thykier-Nielsen S , Jacobsen LH , Hoe SC , et al . Requirements for estimation of doses from contaminants dispersed by a ‘dirty bomb’ explosion in an urban area . J Environ Radioact . 2009 ; 100 ( 12 ): 1005 - 11 .

Giardina M , Buffa P . A new approach for modeling dry deposition velocity of particles . Atmospheric Environm . 2018 ; 180 : 11 - 22 .

Freudenberg D . Risikoanalyseansätze, Simulation und irreguläre Kräfte . Mil Power Revue der Schweizer Armee . 2011 ; 2 : 11 - 9 .

Graham JD , Johansson PO , Nakanishi J . The role of efficiency in risk management . In: McDaniels T , Small MJ , editors. Risk analysis and society: an interdisciplinary characterization of the field . Cambridge : Cambridge University Press ; 2003 . p. 251 – 86 .

Reisman AM , Farrell K , Leitman M . Value analysis of the costliest elective lifesaving procedures at an academic medical center . J Sci Innov Med . 2018 ; 1 ( 1 ): 2 . https://doi.org/10.29024/jsim.2 https://doi.org/10.29024/jsim.2 .

Tengs TO , Adams ME , Pliskin JS , Safran DG , Siegel JE , Weinstein MC , et al . Five-hundred life-saving interventions and their cost-effectiveness . Risk Anal . 1995 ; 15 ( 3 ): 369 - 90 .

Miller TR . Variations between countries in values of statistical life . J Transp Econ Policy . 2000 ; 34 ( 2 ): 169 - 88 .

Rump A , Stricklin D , Lamkowski A , Eder S , Port M . Benefit-cost analysis of radiocesium decorporation by a Prussian blue treatment and stockpiling . Drug Res . 2018 ; 68 ( 2 ): 89 - 99 .

Spengler H . Kompensatorische Lohndifferenziale und der Wert eines statistischen Lebens in Deutschland . Zeitschrift für ArbeitsmarktForschung (ZAF) . 2004 ; 3 : 269 - 305 .

Claxton K , Martin S , Soares M , Rice N , Spackman E , Hinde S , et al . Methods for the estimation of the NICE cost effectiveness threshold. Revised report following referees comments: Centre for Health Economics, Department of Economics and Related Studies . North Yorkshire : University of York, Office of Health Economics, Imperial College London ; 2013 .

Meacock R , Doran T , Sutton M . What are the costs and benefits of providing comprehensive seven-day services for emergency hospital admissions? Health Econ . 2015 ; 24 ( 8 ): 907 - 12 .

Views

Downloads

CSCD

Alert me when the article has been cited

Submit

Tools

Publicity Resources

Estimation of radiation-induced health hazards from a "dirty bomb" attack with radiocesium under different assault and rescue conditions

Diagnostic efficacy of fecal-based miR-92a for advanced colorectal neoplasia: a prospective multicenter screening trial

Effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of risk-adapted colorectal cancer screening: a randomized controlled trial and modeling analysis

Molecular diagnostic approaches for enteric parasites: an issue of relevance for deployed soldiers?

Research on Driving Equipment Suspension Parameters and the Structures of Locomotives with Motor Elastically Mounted on the Frame

Related Author

Andreas Lamkowski

Jia-Chen Wang

Li Zhao

Xiang-Yang Yu

Ting-Ping Wu

Chang-Fa Xia

Ju-Fang Shi

Hui He

Related Institution

Tianjin Third Central Hospital, Tianjin University

Office of Cancer Screening, National Cancer Center/National Clinical Research Center for Cancer/Cancer Hospital, Chinese Academy of Medical Sciences and Peking Union Medical College

Department of Health Management, Shenzhen People’s Hospital, the Second Clinical Medical College of Jinan University/the First Affiliated Hospital of Southern University of Science and Technology

Department of Gastrointestinal Surgery, Tianjin Nankai Hospital, Tianjin Medical University

Department of Gastroenterology, Shenzhen Bao’an Traditional Chinese Medicine Hospital

⁰